2. Level - Identity Consciousness

The World of Belonging and Division

The second level of consciousness emerges as the first level expands beyond its initial, undifferentiated state and begins to form distinct identities. This shift is marked by a growing sense of self in relation to others, where meaning, connection, and belonging take precedence over pure instinct.

This level is defined by the human tendency to seek safety, meaning, control, and validation through group affiliation. The individual begins to form a sense of identity beyond instinctive reactions, but their thoughts, emotions, and actions are primarily shaped by the emerging collective narratives, cultural conditioning, and societal structures that form within this level.

At this level, signs of fragmentation begin to emerge. The sense of unity that characterized the first level starts to dissolve as the individual differentiates themselves from others and from nature. However, this fragmentation remains relatively low in intensity, as the experience of belonging to a group still provides a sense of connection to something greater than oneself. The identification with collective structures acts as a buffer, mitigating the full impact of separation that becomes more pronounced in later levels.

Keywords

• Myth and Dogma—The world is understood through collective stories, religious doctrines, and ideological narratives that shape identity.
• Gods and Symbols—Worship shifts from natural forces to personalized deities. Religious and ideological symbols replace the direct connection with life.
• Heaven and Hell—Dualistic thinking emerges, reinforcing moral absolutes and structured belief systems.
• Tribe and Civilization—The transition from small kinship groups to organized societies solidifies collective identities.
• Priests and Kings—Spiritual and divine rulers become the central authorities, intertwining religious and worldly power to shape order and belief.
• Devotion and Loyalty—Faith and allegiance to a group, a leader, or a higher cause become primary virtues.
• Magic and Ritual—Structured practices replace spontaneous spiritual experiences, reinforcing communal cohesion.
• The First Separation—A growing distinction between self and the external world introduces the seeds of fragmentation.
• Little Ego, Growing Identity—While the personal ego is still developing, group identity takes precedence over individuality.
• Fiction and Ideology—Shared narratives become the foundation of collective reality, shaping law, ethics, and social order.

Historical

This level marks the decisive break from the undifferentiated awareness of the previous level. The world is no longer experienced as an interconnected whole, but through distinctions, categories, and group identities. The emergence of fictive language, around 70,000 years ago, played a crucial role in this transformation, allowing humans to construct shared narratives, myths, and belief systems that extended beyond immediate reality.

With this development, duality was born. Humans could now exist in at least two realities: the tangible world of direct experience and the abstract world of stories, symbols, and imagined structures. This shift gave rise to the first real separation—from nature, from each other, and from an unbroken sense of being.

At this point, identity became a central organising force in human consciousness. The need for security and belonging drove the formation of tribes, religions, and civilizations, each bound together by shared myths and symbols. However, as much as these structures created unity within groups, they also laid the foundation for division, exclusion, and conflict. Humanity had entered an era where belief could override direct perception, leading to manipulation, dogma, and ideological warfare.

The fragmentation that began at this level remains deeply ingrained in human societies. Even today, a significant portion of humanity operates within this framework, shaped by attachment to collective identities, ideological narratives, and the security of belonging.

Identity

At birth, we exist in a state of undivided awareness, immersed in the present without distinction between self and world. This belongs to the first level of consciousness, where there is no separation, only direct experience. Over time, the first separation occurs—the emergence of a personal identity. The realization of 'I exist' introduces the fundamental shift, marking the beginning of self-awareness and differentiation.

In childhood, the world appears enchanted, where reality and imagination blend seamlessly. This period is characterized by an instinctive trust in parents, leaders, and external forces. However, as we grow, our identity becomes shaped by cultural, social, and ideological conditioning. These structures unfold in specific beliefs and worldviews, reinforcing a collective sense of belonging while limiting independent thought.

This level of consciousness provides comfort through group identification, but also restricts personal evolution. Remaining in this state throughout life means living within predefined narratives rather than engaging in deeper self-inquiry.

"Growing up is terribly hard to do. It is much easier to skip and go from one childhood to another."—F. Scott Fitzgerald.

Core Characteristics of Identity Consciousness

• Emotional Attachment to Beliefs: Individuals at this level do not critically analyze their worldviews; they adopt them from their surroundings and defend them passionately, equating challenges to their beliefs with personal attacks. This attachment can result in fundamentalist tendencies, where alternative perspectives are dismissed or perceived as threats, leading to religious, ideological, and political extremism.
• Group Affiliation: The primary drive in this level is the need for belonging. People define themselves through national, religious, ideological, or cultural identities, seeing the world through the lens of “us versus them and/or that.”
• Hierarchical Thinking: Authority figures—whether political leaders, religious institutions, or ideological movements—are viewed as sources of absolute truth. This leads to obedience and conformity rather than independent reasoning.
• Conflict and Division: Since identity is built on differentiation from others, this level is prone to polarization, discrimination, and hostility toward opposing groups. It fosters nationalism, sectarianism, and ideological warfare.
• Moral Dualism: The world is perceived in black and white—good versus evil, right versus wrong. There is little room for nuance, as individuals seek certainty rather than complexity.

Relation to Society and Power Structures

A defining feature of this level is the lack of self-determination, which leads to an increased reliance on leadership. Individuals look to external authorities—whether political, religious, or ideological—to provide guidance, validation, and meaning. This dependence on leadership reinforces hierarchical structures and discourages independent thought, as conformity ensures security within the group.

Identity Consciousness is the foundation of mass political and religious movements. Governments, corporations, and ideologies thrive by shaping collective identities and mobilising people through emotional narratives.

• Politics: At this level, political systems in general function as arenas for identity groups, each seeking dominance rather than mutual understanding. Even in democracies, mechanisms such as emotional mobilisation, slogans, and tribal loyalty take precedence over reasoned discourse. Populism flourishes across political structures. Elections are driven by emotions, slogans, and tribal loyalty rather than reasoned discourse.
• Religion and Ideology: The individual surrenders personal responsibility to the doctrines of a larger group, finding comfort in shared belief systems. Dissent is suppressed, and alternative viewpoints are rejected as threats.
• Social Cohesion and Exclusion: While this level creates strong bonds within a community as long as cohesion remains intact, it simultaneously generates hostility toward outsiders, leading to systemic discrimination, oppression, and ideological extremism.

Limitations of Identity Consciousness

The fragmentation that emerges at this level has profound consequences. As identity becomes the primary framework for interaction, the division between groups deepens, leading to conflict, war, and systemic destruction. The natural world, once experienced as life itself, is now perceived as a resource to be exploited, accelerating environmental devastation. At the same time, it is increasingly seen as an enemy, as its forces—diseases, natural disasters, and ecological shifts—threaten the stability of human societies.

Moreover, thinking itself begins to take precedence over life. Concepts, ideologies, and abstractions become more important than direct experience, further detaching individuals from reality. People are willing to fight, suffer, and even die for ideas, without questioning their validity. This mental domination reinforces collective illusions, making it difficult to perceive life beyond constructed narratives.

Despite providing individuals with security and purpose, this level remains fundamentally limited by its lack of self-awareness. The individual does not recognize their conditioning and remains trapped in collective narratives. This level cannot foster true progress or wisdom, as it is driven by emotion rather than insight.

Transition to the Next Level

Moving beyond Identity Consciousness requires the development of personal responsibility, self-inquiry, and the ability to question inherited beliefs. It is only when an individual begins to think beyond their group’s perspective that they can enter the next level—the Personal Consciousness—where independent reasoning and self-determination begin to take root.

---

Related reading